Best Pizza in Morgantown
Updated October 2026 · 8 places · Morgantown
These eight pizza places have Morgantown, West Virginia addresses and recent evidence of operation. The list prioritizes locally rooted pizzerias; it excludes nearby-town locations and national chains. Addresses and current-operation details are drawn from the cited listings or official pages, while the descriptions summarize reviews or local coverage.
Map coming soon
Our Picks
Pizza Al’s
2952 University Ave, Morgantown, WV 26505
Pizza Al’s is a local pizza and sandwich shop that has served Morgantown for years. Reviewers praise its pizza, with one describing it as among the best in northern West Virginia and southwestern Pennsylvania.
Home Grown Pizza
3429 Earl L Core Rd, Morgantown, WV 26508
Home Grown Pizza is a locally reviewed pizza restaurant whose listing also identifies salads and sandwiches. Local coverage points to its distinctive specials and generous toppings, and reviewers describe the pizza as enjoyable.
Devino’s Pizzeria
200 Hornbeck Rd, Morgantown, WV 26508
Devino’s is a Morgantown pizzeria serving pizza and sandwiches. Review summaries praise its pizza crust, including a reviewer who singled out the crust and house-made ranch.
2G Brothers Pizza
23 Cheat Landing, Morgantown, WV 26508
2G Brothers is a family-owned restaurant serving hand-tossed New York-style pizza made with dough prepared in-house daily. Customer comments on its site describe the pizza as a favorite and mention its fresh dough and homemade sauce.
Nonno Carlo
1016 Suncrest Town Centre Dr, Morgantown, WV 26505
Nonno Carlo is an Italian deli and casual restaurant serving sandwiches and pizza. Its website says it makes Pizza Napoletana to order, and a reviewer described the wood-fired pizzas as crisp and flavorful.
Picasso Pizza & Pasta
1370 University Ave, Morgantown, WV 26505
Picasso Pizza & Pasta is a Morgantown restaurant serving pizza and Italian food. Recent customer feedback describes its pizza as good, while one reviewer noted that it had a little spice.
Pizza Al’s II
1403 Earl L Core Rd, Morgantown, WV 26505
Pizza Al’s II is a Morgantown pizza shop listed at the Earl L Core Road address. Local restaurant coverage includes Pizza Al’s II among Morgantown’s pizza options; the available evidence confirms the location but provides little specific review detail about its style.
Fat Angelo’s Pizzeria
750 Fairmont Rd, Morgantown, WV 26501
Fat Angelo’s is a West Virginia pizza business with a Morgantown location serving pizza and other casual dishes. Reviewers mention specialty pizzas and calzones, and some praise its pizza and plentiful toppings.